No Doubt About It: Quality Drama in Dublin
 Father Flynn (Joe Dellacqua) and Sister James (Erin Fisher)
by Krista Threadgill
The Emerald City Players opened their latest production last night. Doubt, the Pulizter-prize winning play by John Patrick Shanley, makes the audience think about the difference between certainty and the truth.
The play is set late in 1963, shortly after John F. Kennedy’s assassination, at a Catholic school already starting to feel the shortage of nuns and priests willing to enter into a religious vocation. During this time, the church has undergone a major reformation in the hopes of making Catholicism more accessible to the people of the parish by becoming less formal, less dour, less old school. The conservative principal of the parish school, Sister Alyosius Beauvier (Suzanne Laird), strongly against these newfangled ideas coming from the patriarchal authority in Rome, continues to run her school more like a prison than a place of open learning. A young teacher, Sister James (Erin Fisher), looking to the principal for guidance and assurance finds only criticism and the advice to “be suspicious.” It soon becomes clear that Sister Alyosius’s suspicions fall on her nemesis, the new priest. Father Brenden Flynn (Joe Dallacqua), she believes, has becoming too interested and engaged with one particular student in the school. Despite a complete lack of evidence—even after interviewing the student’s mother, Mrs. Muller (Tiffany Plummer)—Sister Alyosius makes it her personal vendetta to expose Father Flynn for the villain that she is sure that he is—no matter what the cost to herself, her school, her staff, her students, or the community at large.
C. Austin Hill directs this wonderful troupe of actors through a superb production. Dallacqua is completely convincing and a true pleasure to watch as he delivers sermons and pleads his case to the intractable Sister Alyosius. Fisher’s performance as the ebullient Sister James is solid; the most unfortunate aspect of this character is the lack of joy we get to see her experience. She spends most of the play looking worried or frightened. Plummer’s performance as the supposed victim’s mother is spot on, as well. She conveys the truth of a black woman’s situation in the middle of the Civil Rights Movement with honesty and dignity. Laird gives Sister Alyosius a vitality all her own, but there is more of a choice toward madness than determination at the basis of her character. One senses that she’s losing her mind as she builds her case against Father Flynn, and her final scene only serves to reinforce her madness rather than to affirm her conviction.
Allison Hill’s sets and Natasha Cline’s costumes are nicely designed. There is an ongoing palette of black, white, and grey throughout that mirrors the underlying themes of the play. Unfortunately, Jarod Wilson’s lighting design is a bit unattractive. Part of the problem is the stage itself; it’s such a deep space that getting the lighting right is a challenge. However, the lighting chosen for outdoor scenes made the actors look greenish, whereas the indoor lighting appeared too harsh and washed everyone out.
Although this play is not for young audiences due to the mature nature of the material discussed, it is a great drama for adults. Doubt asks the audience to consider the effects of gossip and jumping to conclusions can bring, not just to an individual, but to an entire community. It’s well worth the price of admission.
Doubt, presented by Emerald City Players, runs Fridays and Saturdays through August 8 with an 8pm curtain, Thursday August 6 at 8pm, and Sunday, August 2 at 2pm. Tickets are $12 for adults, $10 for students and seniors, and $4.50 for students from Columbus State with Live Performance Voucher. Purchase is available online here (additional $0.75 service fee per ticket), or at the door. Performances are held at 6799 Dublin Center Dr., Dublin. For more information see the Columbus Theatre Calendar entry for the corresponding date, visit the Emerald City Players website or call 614-470-1525.
*****
Krista Threadgill spent her childhood following her parents around the Actors Guild of Parkersburg. After that, she wiled away her summers at Jenny Wiley Amphitheater, and she has performed in two Neil Simon plays. She has an English degree from the Ohio State University.
|
Have Faith in This Doubt
 Mrs. Muller (Tiffany Plummer) and Sister Aloysius (Suzanne Laird)
by Danielle Filas
Fresh off the herculean task of hosting Central Ohio’s successful OCTAFest, the Emerald City Players yet again shows its ambitious spirit by tackling John Patrick Shanley’s parable, Doubt. C. Austin Hill directs this Pulitzer Prize and Tony Award winning script made famous by the film version, which garnered multiple nominations from the Academy Awards and Golden Globes, to name a few. The plot of this four character drama focuses on a conservative Bronx Catholic School in the tumultuous dawn of the Civil Rights Era. Principal of the school, Sister Aloysius Beauvier (Suzanne Laird), suspects the priest, Father Flynn (Joe Dalacqua), of improper relations with the school’s first black student. Caught up in the principal’s dogged investigation are the young and idealistic Sister James (Erin Fisher) and the boy’s mother, Mrs. Muller (Tiffany Plummer). The world presented in the script mirrors reality in that nothing is ever black and white. And as Hill writes in his program notes, “…found in this realm of grey is the enemy of faith- doubt.”
Hill presents a strongly unified production, neatly integrating the stage elements to reflect his stated central image, washing the stage and the actors in hues of black, white and grey. Allison Hill’s set splits the space, with half the playing area devoted to Sister Aloysius’s white washed office; the other half in greys and black represents the courtyard. Splitting the set sits a prominently colorful stained glass window, replete with the looming cross. Although the black draping tends to swallow the black costumes of the nuns and priest, the smart concept works with C. Austin Hill’s directorial vision. Further supporting the theme, costumer Natasha Cline spikes the dark hues of her convincing and pitch perfect clergy with contrasts. Father Flynn’s ornate ceremonial garb blasts in luscious gold, a beaming light of faith in the dark and doubtful gloom. Mrs. Muller, too, contrasts the darkness in her stunning white dress and jacket, vaguely reminiscent of Jackie O. Jarod Wilson’s lighting proves adequate, though somewhat flat and with a bizarre greenish hue in the courtyard.
C. Austin Hill also assembles a strong cast, and each talented actor has at least one moment on stage that spotlights that talent. Plummer brings to the role of Mrs. Muller a tightly coiled energy, playing her one scene with a combination of fear, anger, and dignity as she explains, “You accept what you’ve got to accept.” Although Erin Fisher does play Sister James as a bit of a one note character, upset through the entire play, she plays with raw honesty the breakdown scene in which she admits to Father Flynn that her doubt of his integrity, of the principal’s accusation, and of her own worth has devastated her “joy of teaching.” As the icy Sister Aloysius, Laird does play the character’s brittleness convincingly. Unfortunately, Laird does not mine from the character a genuine concern for and desire to protect the innocent child under her care. Instead, Laird at times devolves Sister Aloysius into an eye rolling, mustache twirling villain- making it easy to doubt her conviction and hard to doubt Father Flynn, thereby missing the complexity of the script. Fortunately, Dallacqua, in a truly seamless powerhouse performance, makes up for this in his subtly shaded portrayal of the at times gregarious, at times explosive Father Flynn. Dallacqua first makes the audience wonder how anyone could suspect the charming priest of hurting a child, then makes the audience wonder if that charm might make him uniquely able to seduce a vulnerable, lonely boy.
Emerald City’s latest production helps make the case that the term “community theatre” does not necessarily mean amateurish theatre. Doubt runs through August 8, but promises to raise questions that will stay in the minds of audience members long after this busy company strikes the set. The show runs 90 minutes and without intermission, so visit the concession stand before curtain time if you want a bottle of water. Seating at ECP has now changed from assigned seating to general admission, so show up early to grab a front row or riser seat for the best view of the action.
*****
Danielle Filas serves as a contributing editor to Theatre Vault. She recently moved from Chicago and holds Theatre degrees from Northwestern University and Knox College. You can visit her personal blog by clicking here.
|